Which of the following Petty Officers should NOT be considered for Detachment for Cause?

The rationale for determining which Petty Officer should not be considered for Detachment for Cause primarily revolves around the evaluation ratings that indicate their performance and conduct within their role. A Petty Officer with an evaluation marked as "SP" (Satisfactory Performance) might present issues concerning their behavior or competency.

In contrast, the other options indicate performances that are more favorable. A "P" (proficient) and "MP" (moderate proficiency) still suggest satisfactory performance, although it may not be outstanding. However, the "EP" (Exceptional Proficiency) rating reflects exemplary performance of the highest standard, which strongly suggests that HM1's conduct and ability are commendable.

Given this context, a BM1 with an SP on their evaluation does not meet the threshold of performance that would render them a valuable asset to the command, which aligns closely with the criteria for consideration for Detachment for Cause. This outlines why the BM1 with the SP rating stands out compared to others who portray a better assessment of their capabilities.