Which Petty Officer should NOT be considered for Detachment for Cause?

The chosen answer indicates that the first-class boatswain's mate (BM1) with a "special" (SP) marking on their current evaluation should not be considered for Detachment for Cause. This choice is correct because a special marking signifies exceptional performance, implying that the individual has been recognized for their superior capabilities and contributions. In the context of considering personnel for Detachment for Cause, such commendable performance is a strong indication that the individual is fulfilling their duties effectively and does not warrant detachment.

When evaluating the other options, the presence of derogatory comments or lack of satisfactory evaluations could be red flags. For instance, a second-class boatswain's mate (BM2) with no derogatory comments might seem stable, but the absence of negative feedback does not automatically elevate them to a position of guaranteed reliability compared to someone with a "special" rating. Similarly, a third-class boatswain's mate (BM3) with only satisfactory evaluations may not stand out as an exemplary performer, and thus could be at risk for Detachment for Cause. Finally, while the BM1 with a recent award has demonstrated some level of accomplishment, without the specific outstanding performance mark, they do not necessarily stand out as strongly as an individual with an SP evaluation.